Quick answer: A health care sharing ministry (often sold as a “health share plan”) is a nonprofit group, usually of Christians. Members send money each month to help pay each other’s medical bills. Monthly costs can be lower than full-price insurance. For example, Liberty HealthShare’s Essential program is $160 to $221 a month for one adult. Christian Healthcare Ministries’ Gold program is $299 per adult (“unit”). But a ministry is not insurance. Nobody is legally required to pay your bills. Pre-existing conditions face waits or limits. And you have to agree to its faith and lifestyle rules.
Why we wrote this, and our promise: many pages about sharing ministries are written by people who earn a commission (a sales fee) when you join. We don’t. eDrugSearch has no financial relationship with any ministry, insurer or broker on this page. Nobody can pay to be listed, and we don’t recommend any of them. We quote each ministry’s own rules and link to them.
What is a health care sharing ministry?
Federal tax law has an exact definition. A health care sharing ministry is an organization (26 U.S.C. §5000A(d)(2)(B)(ii)):
- that is a 501(c)(3) tax-exempt nonprofit (a type of charity),
- whose members “share a common set of ethical or religious beliefs and share medical expenses among members in accordance with those beliefs,” no matter which state they live or work in,
- whose members keep their membership even after they develop a medical condition,
- that (or an earlier group it came from) has existed, and shared members’ medical expenses without a break, since at least December 31, 1999, and
- that has a yearly audit by an independent CPA firm (outside accountants) and makes it available to the public on request.
That definition was written into the Affordable Care Act (ACA) so members wouldn’t owe the penalty for not having insurance. Congress cut that penalty to $0 for months after December 31, 2018 (Public Law 115-97, §11081). So today the definition matters mostly as a label. Some groups that call themselves “health shares” don’t meet it.
“Not insurance”: what that really means for you
This is the single most important thing to understand.
State law says so. Several states have laws saying sharing ministries are not insurance. Texas, for example, requires ministries to give members this notice (Texas Insurance Code §1681.002):
“Notice: This health care sharing ministry facilitates the sharing of medical expenses and is not an insurance company, and neither its guidelines nor its plan of operation is an insurance policy. Whether anyone chooses to assist you with your medical bills will be totally voluntary because no other participant will be compelled by law to contribute toward your medical bills. … Regardless of whether you receive any payment for medical expenses or whether this ministry continues to operate, you are always personally responsible for the payment of your own medical bills. Complaints concerning this health care sharing ministry may be reported to the office of the Texas attorney general.”
Virginia, Idaho and West Virginia have similar laws (Virginia, Idaho, West Virginia).
The ministries say so too. Samaritan Ministries’ guidelines say: “Health care sharing is not insurance. Members share one another’s medical expenses through voluntary giving, not because of legal obligation” (Samaritan Guidelines, October 2026). Christian Healthcare Ministries says on its own glossary page that “CHM is not insurance” (CHM).
What that means for you:
- No guarantee of payment. A bill may not be paid if it doesn’t fit the guidelines, or if members don’t share enough.
- No ACA protections. Ministries don’t have to cover pre-existing conditions, the ten essential health benefits or preventive care. And there’s no federal out-of-pocket limit (a yearly cap on what you pay).
- A different place to complain. In Texas, for example, complaints go to the attorney general, not the insurance department (see the notice above).
- No premium tax credit. Tax credits only apply to Marketplace insurance plans.
In plain English: if a ministry doesn’t pay a bill, the bill is still yours.
How sharing works, step by step
- You join, agree to the ministry’s statement of faith and lifestyle rules, and pay a monthly amount.
- You get care. At Samaritan, members deal with providers “as ‘cash-pay’ patients” (Samaritan Guidelines).
- You pay the first part of each bill yourself. Each ministry has its own name for this. Medi-Share calls it the Annual Household Portion. Samaritan calls it the Initial Unshareable Amount. CHM calls it Personal Responsibility. Liberty calls it the Annual Unshared Amount.
- You submit the bills. The ministry checks them against its guidelines.
- Other members share the eligible amounts, up to the ministry’s limits.
The big comparison table
| Medi-Share (Complete) | Samaritan (Classic / Basic) | CHM (Gold / Silver / Bronze) | Liberty (Essential) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly cost | No price list; Medi-Share’s online calculator shows the amount, which depends on how many people join (one, two, or three or more), the oldest one’s age and the Annual Household Portion you pick (Medi-Share calculator; Medi-Share) | Quote only; depends on Classic or Basic, how many people are on the membership and the oldest one’s age (Samaritan Guidelines) | $299 / $169 / $115 per unit a month. Each adult is one unit, all children together are one unit, and no family pays for more than three (CHM; CHM glossary) | Single $160–$221; Couple $261–$382; Family $429–$609, by age, plus $65 for each member over four (Liberty) |
| What you pay first | $3,000, $6,000, $9,000 or $12,000 a year per household ($1,000 option for unmarried members 18–29) (Medi-Share) | $1,000 (Classic) or $2,000 (Basic) per need (Samaritan Guidelines) | Two amounts, both $1,250 / $3,000 / $6,000: each incident’s bills must add up to at least this much to qualify, and each unit pays a “Personal Responsibility” of the same amount once each calendar year before sharing starts (CHM; CHM glossary) | $4,000 / $8,000 / $12,000 a year (single / couple / family) (Liberty) |
| After that | Shared, with a $50 provider fee per visit and $500 for the ER (Medi-Share) | Classic: shared at 100% (maternity at 70%). Basic: shared at 90%, so you pay 10% of qualifying bills; maternity works differently (see below) (Samaritan; Samaritan Guidelines) | Shared up to the cap (CHM) | You pay a co-share: 20% through 2026, cut to 10% for care on or after January 1, 2027 (Liberty) |
| Most shared | No annual or lifetime limit on eligible bills; up to $50,000 in your first month (Medi-Share; Medi-Share) | $500,000 per need (Classic) / $497,500 (Basic); a “Save to Share” program covers amounts above that (Samaritan Guidelines, October 2026) | $125,000 per illness, unless you add CHM Plus ($42 a month) (CHM) | $600,000 per incident (Liberty) |
| Pre-existing conditions | Not shared at first. After 36 months, up to $100,000 a year; after 60 months, up to $500,000 a year (Medi-Share) | Generally not shared unless you’ve gone at least 12 months without symptoms, treatment or medicine (up to five years for some conditions) (Samaritan Guidelines) | Gold: up to $15,000 in year 1, $50,000 total by year 3, then no longer treated as pre-existing. Silver/Bronze: only through voluntary “CHM Give” (CHM) | Not shared in year 1; up to $50,000 total in months 13–35; no pre-existing limit from month 37 (Liberty) |
| Prescriptions | For each new condition, shared for 6 months from diagnosis, including maintenance drugs; never for pre-existing conditions (Medi-Share) | Up to a 120-day supply per need, bought within 120 days of the first prescription (Samaritan Guidelines) | Shared for up to the first 90 days of treatment for a shared incident. After that, long-term (“maintenance”) drugs aren’t shared (CHM FAQ) | Not shared on Essential (Liberty) |
| Maternity | Married members with a $3,000+ household portion, member from conception; up to $125,000 per pregnancy (Medi-Share) | Classic: up to $497,000, shared at 70% (your co-share is capped at $3,000). Basic: $5,000 shared first, then you pay a 10% co-share up to $13,500, then sharing resumes up to $486,500 (Samaritan Guidelines) | Due date at least 300 days after joining (CHM FAQ); you pay $2,500 / $5,000 / $9,000 first (CHM) | Member for 6 straight months before conception (Liberty) |
| Faith and lifestyle | Statement of faith, regular church attendance, no tobacco or illegal drugs for 12 months (Medi-Share) | Statement of faith; every adult attends a Biblical, Christian church at least three of four weeks a month, health and weather permitting (Samaritan Guidelines) | Adults must be Christians who attend worship regularly as health permits; no tobacco or nicotine (including vaping), illegal drugs or “sexual immorality” (CHM FAQ) | “Statement of Shared Christian Beliefs”; no tobacco in any form (including vaping) and no illegal drugs; Essential is for people under 65 (Liberty Sharing Guidelines, Aug 1, 2026) |
Not in the table: other ministries and “health share” programs exist. Some aren’t faith-based or don’t meet the federal definition above. We’ll add them once we’ve read their own published guidelines.
Monthly cost vs a Marketplace plan: a worked example
One adult, age 40, 2027. This is our math, and your numbers will differ. Estimates, not quotes.
| Monthly cost | What you pay before help starts | Has to pay? | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Average Marketplace benchmark silver plan, full price | $703 (KFF) | The plan’s deductible; capped at $12,000 a year total out-of-pocket (CMS) | Yes, for covered care |
| Same plan with a tax credit, income $40,000 | about $289 (estimate, IRS table) | Same | Yes |
| Liberty Essential, single, age 35–49 | $180 (Liberty) | $4,000 a year, then a 10% co-share in 2027, up to $600,000 per incident | No |
| CHM Gold, one adult | $299 (CHM) | $1,250 each calendar year (CHM’s “Personal Responsibility”), and each incident’s bills must reach $1,250 to qualify; up to $125,000 per illness without CHM Plus (CHM glossary) | No |
What this shows: at full price, a ministry can cost far less each month. With a tax credit, the gap can shrink a lot. And only the insurance plan has a yearly cap on what you pay and a legal duty to pay covered claims. Above 400% of the poverty line there’s no tax credit at all in 2027 (IRS). So the full-price row is what those households compare against.
Want a rough number for your own state, age and household? Our free cost estimator shows a typical Marketplace price and an estimate after the tax credit. It also shows the published ministry amounts, side by side. Nothing you type is saved. Try the cost estimator.
Pros and cons of health share plans
The main pro is a lower monthly cost. The main con is that nothing guarantees your bills get paid. Here’s how that plays out:
Possible pros
- Lower monthly cost at full price. In our worked example, Liberty Essential is $180 a month and CHM Gold is $299. The average benchmark plan is $703 before any tax credit.
- Some publish their prices. CHM and Liberty list theirs. Medi-Share and Samaritan give prices by quote.
- High or no sharing limits at some. Medi-Share has no annual or lifetime limit on eligible bills. Liberty Essential shares up to $600,000 per incident.
Possible cons
- Not insurance. Nobody is legally required to pay, and you stay responsible for your bills.
- Pre-existing conditions face waits or limits, usually for one to five years.
- Caps at some. CHM shares up to $125,000 per illness unless you add CHM Plus.
- Prescriptions may be limited. Liberty Essential doesn’t share them, and CHM stops after 90 days of treatment.
- No tax credit and no federal out-of-pocket limit.
- Faith and lifestyle rules apply to every adult member.
Whether that trade-off makes sense depends on your health, your budget and how much risk you can carry. We don’t rank them.
Pre-existing conditions
Every ministry above limits sharing for conditions you had before joining, usually for one to five years. That’s the biggest difference from ACA insurance. ACA insurance can’t charge you more or refuse to cover a pre-existing condition. Have an ongoing condition? Then the exact wording in each ministry’s guidelines decides whether a bill is shared. They’re linked in the table.
Prescriptions
This is where ministries differ the most. It matters if you take medicine every month:
- Liberty Essential doesn’t share prescription medications at all.
- Medi-Share shares prescriptions for a new condition for 6 months from diagnosis. It never shares them for pre-existing conditions.
- Samaritan shares up to a 120-day supply per need.
- CHM shares prescriptions tied to a shared incident (one illness or injury) for up to the first 90 days of treatment. After that, long-term (“maintenance”) drugs aren’t shared (CHM FAQ).
Pregnancy and maternity
All four have waiting periods or membership rules for maternity sharing (see the table). Samaritan (both levels) and CHM also ask you to pay more of a maternity bill yourself than of other bills.
Faith and lifestyle rules
All four ask every adult member to accept a statement of faith and follow lifestyle rules. Examples include church attendance and no tobacco or illegal drugs (see the table). Breaking the rules can affect whether your bills are shared.
What state regulators have found
- Colorado requires sharing ministries and similar plans to report data every year. Its newest report came out in October 2025 and covers 2024. Colorado members submitted $248.6 million in bills for sharing. Of that, $135.7 million was found eligible, and $87.4 million had been paid (Colorado Division of Insurance). The report also listed exclusions. They include mental health treatment and medications for chronic or pre-existing conditions. They also include maternity care unless the mother has been a member for 12 months. Not every group excludes every item.
- Membership: in that report, CHM said it had 351,493 members nationwide. Samaritan said 349,396, and Liberty 43,388. Medi-Share asked for its numbers to be kept confidential (Colorado Division of Insurance).
- Ohio: the Ohio Attorney General investigated Liberty HealthShare over “failure to timely share and pay the bills submitted for sharing.” It was resolved on August 31, 2021. It ended with an Assurance of Voluntary Compliance (a written promise to follow the law) and $25,000 for investigation costs (Ohio Attorney General 2022 report).
In plain English: in Colorado, just over half the dollars sent in were found eligible. About a third had been paid (our math from the report).
Questions to ask before joining any sharing ministry
- What’s the monthly amount for my household, in writing?
- What do I pay first, and is it per year or per need?
- What’s the most you’ll share for one illness or one year?
- How do you handle my pre-existing conditions, by name?
- Do you share prescriptions? Which ones, and for how long?
- How long does it usually take to share a bill?
- What happens if not enough members share in a given month?
- How do I appeal a decision, and who reviews it?
- Which state laws apply to you where I live?
- Can I read your full guidelines before I join?
Frequently asked questions
Is a health care sharing ministry the same as insurance?
No. Ministries aren’t insurance companies. Sharing is voluntary, and members stay responsible for their own bills (Texas Insurance Code §1681.002; Samaritan Guidelines).
Health share plans vs insurance: what’s the difference?
Insurance has to pay covered claims, and a health share plan doesn’t. ACA insurance can’t refuse to cover a pre-existing condition. It also caps what you pay each year for covered, in-network care: $12,000 for one person in 2027 (CMS). Health share plans don’t have to do either, and tax credits can’t be used for them. They can cost less each month, as the worked example above shows.
What are the pros and cons of health share plans?
The main pro is a lower monthly cost, mostly compared with a full-price plan. The main con is that nothing guarantees payment. Others include waits for pre-existing conditions, caps, limited drug sharing, and faith rules. The section above has the numbers.
Are there non-religious health share plans?
The federal definition says members share “a common set of ethical or religious beliefs.” So the definition itself doesn’t require a religion (26 U.S.C. §5000A). But a group (or an earlier group it came from) must have been sharing members’ medical expenses without a break since at least December 31, 1999 to meet it. Some programs that call themselves “health shares” aren’t faith-based or don’t meet the federal definition. We haven’t read their published guidelines yet, so we don’t list them here.
Which is better, Samaritan Ministries or Medi-Share?
Neither is better for everyone, and we don’t rank them. Samaritan Basic shares 90% of qualifying bills, so members pay 10% (Samaritan). With Samaritan, you pay $1,000 or $2,000 per need before sharing starts. Medi-Share uses a yearly household amount from $3,000 to $12,000 instead. Their rules on prescriptions, pre-existing conditions and maternity differ too (see the table). We didn’t find a published monthly price list from either one.
Medi-Share vs Christian Healthcare Ministries: what’s different?
CHM publishes its prices: $299, $169 or $115 per unit a month. It uses two set amounts. First, each incident’s bills must reach a minimum to qualify. Second, each unit pays a yearly “Personal Responsibility” before sharing starts. Both are $1,250, $3,000 or $6,000, depending on the program. There’s a $125,000 cap per illness unless you add CHM Plus. Medi-Share gives prices by quote, uses a yearly household amount, and has no annual or lifetime limit on eligible bills (CHM; CHM glossary; Medi-Share).
What is the downside of Medi-Share?
Like every sharing ministry, it isn’t insurance and doesn’t guarantee payment. Prescriptions for pre-existing conditions are never shared. And pre-existing conditions wait 36 months before limited sharing (Medi-Share).
How much does Christian Healthcare Ministries cost?
CHM lists $299 (Gold), $169 (Silver) and $115 (Bronze) per unit per month. The optional CHM Plus is $42 more. Each adult is one unit, and all children together count as one. So no family pays for more than three units (CHM; CHM glossary).
Can I use a tax credit for a sharing ministry?
No. Premium tax credits apply only to Marketplace health insurance plans.
Can I pay for a sharing ministry from an HSA, or deduct it?
That’s unsettled. In 2020 the IRS proposed treating sharing-ministry memberships as deductible medical costs, as a kind of “medical insurance” (Federal Register). But we haven’t found a final rule. IRS Publication 502 for 2025 doesn’t mention them (IRS). And a Senate bill to make them deductible (S. 653) hasn’t moved past committee (Congress.gov). Also, IRS Publication 969 says HSA money generally can’t pay insurance premiums, with a few exceptions (IRS). A tax professional can tell you how it applies to you.
Are health share plans worth it?
It depends on your health, your budget and how much risk you can carry. They often cost less each month. But they come with caps, waiting periods and no guarantee. The worked example above shows how the gap with a Marketplace plan changes once a tax credit is counted.
Sources and disclosure
Every rule and price above comes from the ministry’s own published guidelines or website, from federal and state law, or from state regulators. Each is linked where it’s used. We re-check this page at least twice a year, and whenever a ministry announces changes.
Last updated: November 21, 2026 · Reviewed by: Dr. Diana Rangaves, PharmD, November 19, 2026
Disclosure: eDrugSearch has no financial relationship with any health care sharing ministry, insurer or broker. Nobody can pay to be listed or ranked, there are no affiliate or referral links, and we earn nothing if you join one. This page is general information, not legal, tax, financial, religious or medical advice. It doesn’t recommend any ministry or plan.
